Player ratings: Blue blitz

Sat, 17 Nov 2012 22:18
Pascal-pape-france-630 Yoann-maestri-france2-630 Pascal-pape-charge630 Louis-picamoles-france-char
At the centre of the blue blitz was flyhalf Frederic Michalak

France continued their impressive year-end form with a deserving 39-22 demolition of a willing Argentina in Lille on Saturday.

Argentina gave as good as they got, but a 21-point blitz by France in the first half set them on course for the victory.

France scored 21 points a 15-minutes period in the first half to go from 3-13 down to 24-13.

At the centre of the blue blitz was flyhalf Frederic Michalak.

Jan de Koning rates the French players!

15 Brice Dulin:
Sublime grubber for Vincent Clerc's second try. Started slowly, even missing a crucial tackle, but once France got on the front foot he came into his own.

14 Wesley Fofana:
He was very quiet in the first half and only had a couple of runs. Injected some pace into the French attacks late in the second half.

13 Florian Fritz:
At first struggled to inject himself into the game, but later managed some powerful runs. Conceded a penalty that gave the Pumas some momentum early in the second half.  Mixed back.

12 Maxime Mermoz:
Missed a tackle that resulted in Pumas' try, but managed some telling runs in the second half.

11 Vincent Clerc:
Showed his finishing ability and did not miss any tackles. Still a quality player.

10 Frederic Michalak:
Failed to find touch from a penalty, but regularly managed to turn the Pumas around  and even slotted a drop-goal - as usual varying between the sublime and ridiculous. But mostly it was sublime.

9 Maxime Machenaud:
Put his team under pressure with poor skills, when he failed to control possession and allowed the Pumas to get on the front foot. For the most part he was a decent link.

8 Louis Picamoles:
Concede a penalty when he tackled Nicolas Sanchez in the air. However, he was again involved in everything - including throwing a crucial pass in the lead-up to Vincent Clerc's first try.

7 Fulgence Ouedraogo:
Was causing havoc on the Puma line-out throws and won all his own throws. His tackle count was just as impressive.

6 Yannick Nyanga:
Great opportunism to step out of two tackles and sprint 40 metres for a sublime try - you have to ask why he has been ignored by the previous coaching regime. Had the highest tackle count of all the French players.

5 Yoann Maestri:
Some strong carries and a few big hits, but also slipped a tackle or two.

4 Pascal Pape (captain):
Worked hard off the ball and made some big hits on defence. Surprised he is not being used more in the line-outs.

3 Nicolas Mas:
Was quiet for most part and also conceded a couple of silly penalties.

2 Dimitri Szarzewski:
Full of energy in the early stages and was good value on defence, but faded as the game wore on.

1 Yannick Forestier:
Concede an offside penalty that cost his team and the later a scrum penalty - he is a liability to his team.


16 Benjamin Kayser (on for Szarzewski, 50th min):
Made no real impact, other than a few tackles.

17 Thomas Domingo (on for Forestier, 50th min):
Made a huge impact on defence and had one of the highest tackle counts in the final quarter - shutting out a  number of Puma raids.

18 Vincent Debaty (on for Mas, 68th min):
Not enough time to be rated.

19 Jocelino Suta (on for Maestri , 60th min):
His carries were largely ineffective, but was sound on defence and took all his line-outs.

20 Damien Chouly (on for Picamoles, 73rd min):
Not enough time to be rated.

21 Morgan Parra (on for Machenaud, 58th min):
Wasn't much better than Machenaud - basically just a link.

22 Francois Trinh-Duc (on for Dulin, 68th min):
Not enough time to be rated.

23 Yoann Huget (on for Fritz, 62nd min):
Slipped more tackles than he made and hardly made ground with the ball in hand.

Newsletter Subscription
Subscribe now to Rugby365 and you'll be able to receive our informative newsletters and access special promotions.