SANZAR not sold on TMO changes

Sun, 16 Dec 2012 12:43
Large greg peters h s 630 Large digby ioane 630 Large aaron cruden v crus 630

SANZAR CEO Greg Peters has intimated that it's unlikely that Super Rugby will adopt television match official rule changes next year.

SANZAR CEO Greg Peters has intimated that it's unlikely that Super Rugby will adopt television match official (TMO) rule changes next year.

Empowering the TMO to review possible infringements during try-scoring movements and incidents of foul play have been trialled in the Currie Cup and English Premiership competitions this year.

Whilst the abbreviated scrum engagement sequence and five-second rule at rucks and mauls will be introduced next year, Peters hinted that any possible rule amendments around the TMO would have to wait until 2014.  

This is partly due to the fact that the Super Rugby season will kick-off on February 15, well before the International Rugby Board (IRB) council would have had time to assess and recommend any findings on the TMO changes, with the council only set to meet again in May.

Peters also fears that implementing the changes could hamper the fluency of the game and feels there is too much subjectivity around the alterations at this stage.  

"I think the jury is still out on this," Peters told Fairfax Media.

"It will be a big ask [to change the rules around the TMO], given the IRB hasn't met to discuss them by the time our competition has started."

"There is also a lot of subjectivity around it - things like who initiates the review, the referee or the TMO? How far do you go back in the movement?

“Was there foul play downfield, was there a forward pass back on the 22m and if it was a line-ball you have to take the camera angle into account too."

New Zealand's Super Rugby franchises also voiced their concerns during a meeting with the New Zealand Rugby Union's high performance referee manager that assistant referees would possibly opt-out of making quick decisions, which would result in more and longer stoppages in play.

"SANZAR will want to be very, very clear on the extent of the protocols if anything is to be changed at all," Peters added.

"We don't want fans to get confused. It can seem simple but it's not. There is so much subjectivity."

Peters said that while SANZAR have not completely dismissed the TMO changes, they remain cautious.

"This is something I would prefer to see introduced across the whole game, not just in selected competitions... if the recommendations are very clear in stating how they should be used it is possible we will implement them," he said. 

There are currently no matches being played
Tue, 06 October 2015
Canada v Romania 15h45 Leicester
Fiji v Uruguay 19h00 Milton Keynes
Wed, 07 October 2015
South Africa v United States 15h45 London
Namibia v Georgia 19h00 Exeter
Fri, 09 October 2015
Pumas v Blue Bulls 16h00 Mbombela Stadium
Western Province v EP Kings 16h00 Newlands
New Zealand v Tonga 19h00 Newcastle
Sat, 10 October 2015
Free State Cheetahs v Sharks 12h00 Bloemfontein
Samoa v Scotland 13h30 Newcastle
Golden Lions v Griquas 14h00 Ellis Park
Australia v Wales 15h45 London
England v Uruguay 19h00 Manchester
Sun, 11 October 2015
Argentina v Namibia 11h00 Leicester
Italy v Romania 13h30 Exeter
France v Ireland 15h45 Cardiff
United States v Japan 19h00 Gloucester
Pool AU
Team P W D L Pts
Waratahs 16 11 0 5 52
Brumbies 16 9 0 7 47
Rebels 16 7 0 9 36
Reds 16 4 0 12 22
Force 16 3 0 13 19
Pool NZ
Team P W D L Pts
Hurricanes 16 14 0 2 66
Highlanders 16 11 0 5 53
Chiefs 16 10 0 6 48
Crusaders 16 9 0 7 46
Blues 16 3 0 13 20
Pool SA
Team P W D L Pts
Stormers 16 10 1 5 45
Lions 16 9 1 6 42
Bulls 16 7 0 9 38
Sharks 16 7 0 9 34
Cheetahs 16 5 0 11 26