Law Discussion: England's try

Tue, 26 Feb 2013 14:19
Large tuilagi scores corner630

The referee freekicks France for early engagement at a scrum. Andy Goode of England steps up and kicks a high up-and-under. England players chase after the ball.

The referee freekicks France for early engagement at a scrum. Andy Goode of England steps up and kicks a high up-and-under. England players chase after the ball.

Vincent Clerc of France fails to catch the ball which is knocked back to Yannick Nyanga, the French flank. England players drive onto Nyanga who loses the ball backwards., The ball is on the ground with players on their feet near it. Tom Wood, the England No.8, kicks the ball forward. It bangs into the leg of Mako Vunipola. From Vunipola's leg the ball squirts out the side of the group of players where Manu Tuilagi picks up the ball. He sets off for the goal-line 40 metres away as Clerc chases him. Tuilagi scores.


Certainly not. Vunipola was in front of Wood. Vunipola was in front of a team-mate who last played the ball. He was in an offside position.

In general play a player is offside if the player is in front of a team-mate who is carrying the ball, or in front of a team-mate who last played the ball. Offside means that a player is temporarily out of the game. Such players are liable to be penalised if they take part in the game.


(a) A player who is in an offside position is liable to sanction only if the player does one of three things:
• Interferes with play or,
• Moves forward, towards the ball or
• Fails to comply with the 10-Metre Law (Law 11.4).
A player who is in an offside position is not automatically penalised.

That would suggest the Vunipola should have been penalised. But...

(a) When an offside player cannot avoid being touched by the ball or by a team-mate carrying it, the player is accidentally offside. If the player’s team gains no advantage from this, play continues. If the player’s team gains an advantage, a scrum is formed with the opposing team throwing in the ball.

Vunipola did not try to play the ball and standing there he had no way of avoiding the short kick,

It should have been a scrum to England.

Easy to detect?

No, not at all. There was a forest of legs and it all happened so quickly.

Ask the TMO?

The referee of the day was not allowed to by the regulations of the Six Nations. He would have loved to use the extended TMO protocol as used in most of the world. That would have allowed him to go back and examine what happened at this incident. It would have enabled the TMO to advise him that it should not have been a try to England but a scrum to France.

The referee would have been used to using it and seeing it used. It may, of course, have made him less alert than he would have been were there none of these aids. But it's hard to justify the reason for not using what is available. It's not as if the TMO would take over the match.

There are currently no matches being played
Sun, 19 February 2017
Sale Sharks v Wasps 15h00 AJ Bell Stadium
Newcastle Falcons v Northampton Saints 15h00 Kingston Park
Mon, 20 February 2017
CUT-Ixias v Shimlas 14h45 Bloemfontein
Maties v NMMU-Madibaz 16h30 Stellenbosch
UWC v Rhodes 16h30 Cape Town
TUT v WSU 16h30 Pretoria
NWU-Pukke v UCT-Ikeys 16h30 Potchefstroom
UKZN-Impi v Fort Hare 16h30 Durban
UJ v UP-Tuks 17h00 Johannesburg
Thu, 23 February 2017
Rebels v Blues 08h45 Melbourne
Fri, 24 February 2017
Highlanders v Chiefs 06h35 Dunedin
Reds v Sharks 09h00 Brisbane
Harlequins v Leicester Tigers 17h45 Twickenham Stoop
Edinburgh v Cardiff Blues 19h05 Myreside
Dragons v Leinster 19h30 Rodney Parade
Munster v Scarlets 19h35 Thomond Park
Sat, 25 February 2017
Sunwolves v Hurricanes 04h15 Tokyo
Crusaders v Brumbies 06h35 Christchurch
Waratahs v Force 08h45 Allianz Park
Saracens v Sale Sharks 12h45 Allianz Park
Exeter Chiefs v Newcastle Falcons 13h00 Sandy Park
Northampton Saints v Worcester Warriors 13h00 Franklin's Gardens
Cheetahs v Lions 13h05 Bloemfontein
Scotland v Wales 14h25 BT Murrayfield
Kings v Jaguares 15h15 Port Elizabeth
Ireland v France 16h50 Aviva Stadium
Stormers v Bulls 17h30 Cape Town
Sun, 26 February 2017
Bristol v Bath 11h00 Ashton Gate
Wasps v Gloucester 12h30 Ricoh Arena
Treviso v Connacht 12h30 Stadio Comunale di Monigo
Zebre v Ulster 12h30 Stadio Sergio Lanfranchi
Ospreys v Glasgow Warriors 13h05 Liberty Stadium
Team P W D L Pts
England 2 2 0 0 8
Ireland 2 1 0 1 6
Wales 2 1 0 1 5
France 2 1 0 1 5
Scotland 2 1 0 1 5
Italy 2 0 0 2 0