Law Discussion: Forward passes

Fri, 03 May 2013 20:22
Large scott higginbotham rebels r Large nickphippsforce Large scott higginbotham aus trai

rugby365 law guru Paul Dobson looks at two incidents in Friday's match between the Rebels and the Chiefs in Melbourne.

In Friday evening's match between the Rebels and the Chiefs in Melbourne, two passes were referred to the TMO to see if they were forward or not.

On each occasion the play resulted in a try and on each occasion the TMO recommended the award of the try.

1. Scott Higginbotham's try.

13/14th minute.

The Rebels attack down the right and right wing Tom English makes good ground. As he is tackled Same Cane of the Chiefs, he lobs the ball infield where Scott Higginbotham of the Rebels grabs it. He is tackled from being by Matt Vant Leven of the Chiefs but manages to stretch out and avoid Gareth Anscombe's right leg to place the ball on the goal-line.

The referee refers the matter to the TMO asking about English's try and the grounding of the ball.

The TMO has just two views - one from well behind English and Higginbotham and one well in front of them. He has no view from the side.

The TMO reports to the referee: "There's nothing to obviously suggest that the pass has gone forward and the grounding was good."

On this information, the referee awards the try.

2. Nick Phipps's try.

66/67th minutes

About eight metres inside his own half, James O'Connor of the Rebels starts running. Blocked by Liam Messam of the Chiefs O'Connor passes to Kurtley Beale on his left. Beale passes back to O'Connor who races ahead, passing to Nick Phipps on his left and Phipps races through for a try.

Again the referee refers the matter to the TMO, again asking for advice on a possible forward pass.

The TMO this time has a reasonable side-on view. He reports to the referee: "You may award the try."

Let us note just a few things:

(i) Law 12 DEFINITION THROW FORWARD
A throw forward occurs when a player throws or passes the ball forward.
‘Forward’ means towards the opposing team’s dead ball line.

(ii) The TMO protocol has this to say on how the TMO is to judge a forward pass.

6. Forward passes

The TMO protocol is very specific on this matter. For the ball to be judged ‘forward’ the ball must be passed forward from a player’s hands and the flight of the ball should not be taken into consideration. If there is no evidence of a forward pass it is helpful if the TMO indicates that by stating; "There is no evidence of a forward pass".

It is about the act of throwing, not the act of catching. It is about how the ball-carrier passes the ball, not where the catcher catches the ball. It is about a forward pass, not a forward catch.

As a result it does not matter what path the ball travels on or how it drifts.

(iii) As is the case with all refereeing decisions, there is an important refereeing principle: if an offence/infringement is not clear and obvious play goes on.

In 1. above, the Scott Higginbotham try, the TMO is referring to this principle when he says that nothing obviously suggests that the pass was forward. The camera position tells you that it is impossible to decide clearly and obviously that English's hands move forward in passing.

In 2 above, the Nick Phipps try, the angle is far better but it is again not clear and obvious that O'Connor's hands move in a forward direction.

(iv) There is the matter of momentum.

Drive your car and when you get opposite a marker have somebody throw a ball out backwards of the marker. Then see where the pall lands relative to the marker. And the faster you drive the further it will be in front of the marker.

Unless the passer is stationary it is extremely hard to prevent the ball from travelling forward. If we were to stop play every time the pass from a moving player travelled forward we would kill rugby. If the referee is moving, he is less likely to note the forward path of the ball but a stationary spectator may well observe it. NOT THAT The PATH OF The PASSED BALL IS RELEVANT.

In the two cases above the TMO was quite correct to make the decision he made for the reasons he gave.

Australia produced a fascinating video which makes this point clear. Please, look at the video clip below!

There are currently no matches being played
FIXTURE GMT VENUE
Fri, 28 April 2017
Highlanders v Stormers 07h35 Dunedin
Cardiff Blues v Zebre 18h05 Cardiff
Edinburgh v Dragons 18h35 Myreside
Leinster v Glasgow Warriors 18h35 RDS Arena
Newcastle Falcons v Worcester Warriors 19h00 Kingston Park
Sat, 29 April 2017
Chiefs v Sunwolves 07h35 Hamilton
Reds v Waratahs 09h45 Suncorp Stadium
Force v Lions 11h55 Perth
Ospreys v Ulster 14h00 Liberty Stadium
Bath v Gloucester 14h00 Recreation Ground
Exeter Chiefs v Northampton Saints 14h00 Sandy Park
Saracens v Bristol 14h00 Allianz Park
Harlequins v Wasps 14h00 Twickenham Stoop
Leicester Tigers v Sale Sharks 14h00 Welford Road
Cheetahs v Crusaders 15h15 Bloemfontein
Treviso v Munster 17h05 Stadio Monigo
Kings v Rebels 17h30 Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium
Connacht v Scarlets 18h35 Sportsground
Jaguares v Sharks 19h40 Buenos Aires
Sun, 30 April 2017
Brumbies v Blues 06h05 Canberra
RESULT SCORE
Sun, 23 April 2017
Clermont Auvergne v Leinster 27 | 22
Sat, 22 April 2017
Sharks v Rebels 9 | 9
Bulls v Cheetahs 20 | 14
Munster v Saracens 10 | 26
Force v Chiefs 7 | 16
Crusaders v Stormers 57 | 24
Highlanders v Sunwolves 40 | 15
Fri, 21 April 2017
Lions v Jaguares 24 | 21
Waratahs v Kings 24 | 26
Hurricanes v Brumbies 56 | 21
Mon, 17 April 2017
UP-Tuks v Maties 28 | 21
Sun, 16 April 2017
Northampton Saints v Saracens 25 | 27
Bristol v Wasps 21 | 36
Sat, 15 April 2017
Connacht v Leinster 24 | 37
Treviso v Edinburgh 21 | 6
SUPER RUGBY
MORE LOGS
Pool AU
Team P W D L Pts
Brumbies 8 3 0 5 17
Reds 8 2 0 6 10
Force 7 2 0 5 9
Waratahs 8 2 0 6 9
Rebels 7 1 1 5 7
Pool NZ
Team P W D L Pts
Crusaders 8 8 0 0 36
Hurricanes 8 7 0 1 33
Chiefs 8 7 0 1 33
Highlanders 8 5 0 3 23
Blues 8 3 0 5 17
Pool SA1
Team P W D L Pts
Stormers 8 6 0 2 26
Bulls 8 3 0 5 14
Cheetahs 8 2 0 6 10
Sunwolves 8 1 0 7 5
Pool SA2
Team P W D L Pts
Lions 8 7 0 1 32
Sharks 8 5 1 2 24
Jaguares 8 4 0 4 20
Kings 8 2 0 6 10