Law Clarification No.7

Law Clarifications have the effect of law. While there are no law changes, there have been seven clarifications in the nine months of 2015 and the 20th Law Clarification since the 2011 Rugby World Cup, the 16th in the last two years.

This one concerns kicking the ball out of the hands of a ball-carrier. It is dated 9 September 2015.

Request

We are concerned at the increasing practice of an opponent kicking the ball out of the hands of a player who has picked up the ball.

This is happening mainly when the ball is won at the breakdown/tackle/ruck and has been picked up by a player. An opponent then kicks the ball from that player’s hands. (This opponent may have legally come through the breakdown, or may still be in the breakdown.)

We do not consider that this action is either:

(i) A fair contest for the ball.

or

(ii) Can be considered a legal means of dispossessing a player.

It is also foreseeable that injuries will occur. It presents difficulties in interpretation and consistency for the referee:

If contact is made with the hands of the player it can be considered foul play – this is difficult to see and to decide.

If the ball is dropped, referees are ruling a knock-on, whereas the player in possession has neither lost possession of the ball, nor has he knocked it forward.

We can find some guidance in the following Laws (22 & 15) which deal with kicking the ball from a player’s possession in the field of play who is reaching out to score, albeit a tackled player:

Law 22.4 (e) Tackled near the goal-line. If a player is tackled near to the opponents’ goal line so that this player may immediately reach out and ground the ball on or over the goal-line, a try is scored.

(f) In this situation, defending players who are on their feet may legally prevent the try by pulling the ball from the tackled player’s hands or arms, but must not kick the ball.

Law 15.6 (j) – This Law is very similar to 22.4 (f) above.

When a tackled player reaches out to ground the ball on or over the goal-line to score a try, an opponent may pull the ball from the player’s possession, but must not kick or attempt to kick the ball.

Sanction: Penalty kick

We consider that it is logical for the rationale in Law to cover the scenario which we have outlined above in relation to the breakdown, and that the Law intends that it is not legal to kick the ball from the hands of a player in possession in any circumstances.

Clarification of the Designated Members of the Rugby Committee

The designated members agree that it is illegal to kick the ball from the hands of a player in possession in any circumstances. An example of this action can be seen at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mONaLz6Ry4&feature=youtu.be. The sanction for this action should be a penalty against the offending team.