O'Shea slams 'knee-jerk' reaction to Italy tactics

Tue, 28 Feb 2017 19:33

REACTION: Conor O'Shea has accepted a change to the game's rules is inevitable, following Italy's controversial 'no-ruck' ploy against England.

However, he warned lawmakers against a "knee-jerk" reaction.

The Italy coach said World Rugby, the sport's global governing body, should delay any change until next season even though England boss Eddie Jones labelled the Azzurri's approach a "joke", with Red Rose flyhalf George Ford calling for immediate action to outlaw a tactic he said threatened to "kill the game".

World Rugby Chairman Bill Beaumont was due to hold informal talks Tuesday at the global governing body's Dublin headquarters with referees' chief Alain Rolland concerning Sunday's match.

But no formal action, if any, is likely until after next week's Dublin meeting of World Rugby's rugby committee at the earliest.

England won 36-15 on Sunday to stay on course for back-to-back Six Nations Grand Slams as they extended their winning run to 17 successive Test victories.

But the result was overshadowed by the debate about Italy's tactics.

The perennial underdogs remarkably led England 10-5 at half-time after repeatedly refusing to commit anyone other than the tackler to the breakdown, meaning no ruck was formed.

As a result, offside became irrelevant and Italy players could stand directly between England's Danny Care and half-back partner Ford.

Afterwards, a frustrated Jones said: "If that's rugby, I'm going to retire. That's not rugby."

The Australian added: "I'm sure Bill Beaumont watched that game and will take some action."

But O'Shea told Tuesday's London Evening Standard: "It shouldn't be done during the season and it shouldn't be a knee-jerk reaction because of one game.

"Will it be amended? I am sure it will at some stage, laws always are."

O'Shea, previously in charge of London club Harlequins, said he was fed up with what he thought was the double-standard applied to Italy

"Wasps did something similar in a European game against Toulouse with Nathan Hughes intercepting the ball and it was tactical genius but when we did it then it's something wrong."

The former Ireland fullback added: "What riled me is that when England beat South Africa last year then it's brilliant and when we beat them last year everyone says they are rubbish.

"Italian rugby has to think outside the norm or else it will never catch up," insisted O'Shea whose side had suffered a 63-10 thrashing by Ireland in Rome in their previous match.

"People talk about David versus Goliath well it wasn't in a normal fist fight that David won.

"Do you think people would be talking about England v Italy like they are? No. People not involved in the game are asking, ‘what was that about?' and ‘what was going on there?' That's brilliant for rugby and you have to encourage people to think outside the box.  

"All we did was do something that has been done a lot and it wasn't new. We just added a bit of surprise because people expected [England to score] 70 points."

The fact England scored five tries in the second half after exploiting the main weakness of the 'no-ruck' ploy -- an unguarded area in front of the tackled player -- suggests a law change may not be necessary.

After Sunday's match, Jones accused referee Romain Poite of looking "flustered", but a World Rugby spokesman told AFP on Monday the Frenchman and his colleagues had "officiated law correctly".

England's James Haskell was involved in a comical incident during the match when, having asked Poite "what the exact rule is", he received the reply: "I can't say, I'm the referee, I'm not a coach".

That prompted Wales' leading international referee Nigel Owens to tell the Daily Telegraph: "I am surprised at players not knowing this because international referees tend to go in with their respective national squads and discuss stuff like this."

Agence France-Presse

There are currently no matches being played
Sat, 24 March 2018
Kings v Treviso 13h00 Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium
Saracens v Harlequins 15h00 London
London Irish v Gloucester 15h00 Madejski Stadium
Sale Sharks v Worcester Warriors 15h00 AJ Bell Stadium
Stormers v Reds 15h15 Newlands
Cardiff Blues v Ulster 15h15 Cardiff Arms Park
Munster v Scarlets 17h30 Thomond Park
Newcastle Falcons v Northampton Saints 17h30 Kingston Park
Ospreys v Leinster 19h35 Liberty Stadium
Jaguares v Lions 19h40 Estadio Jose Amalfitani
Sun, 25 March 2018
Leicester Tigers v Wasps 15h00 Welford Road
Fri, 30 March 2018
Chiefs v Highlanders 06h35 Hamilton
Rebels v Hurricanes 08h45 Melbourne
Scarlets v La Rochelle 17h30 Parc y Scarlets
Sat, 31 March 2018
Blues v Sharks 06h35 Eden Park
Sat, 24 March 2018
Hurricanes v Highlanders 29 | 12
Sunwolves v Chiefs 10 | 61
Fri, 23 March 2018
Bath v Exeter Chiefs 18 | 20
Dragons v Cheetahs 17 | 29
Glasgow Warriors v Zebre 68 | 7
Connacht v Edinburgh 22 | 29
Rebels v Sharks 46 | 14
Crusaders v Bulls 34 | 14
Mon, 19 March 2018
CUT-Ixias v UCT-Ikeys 23 | 30
Wits v NWU-Pukke 31 | 35
Shimlas v NMMU-Madibaz 28 | 22
UP-Tuks v UJ 30 | 30
Sun, 18 March 2018
Waratahs v Rebels 51 | 27
Sat, 17 March 2018
Jaguares v Reds 7 | 18
Wales v France 14 | 13
Team P W D L Pts
Ireland 5 5 0 0 26
Wales 5 3 0 2 15
Scotland 5 3 0 2 13
France 5 2 0 3 11
England 5 2 0 3 10
Italy 5 0 0 5 1