Moore slates ELVs
Mon, 05 May 2008 12:15
Former England hooker Brian Moore believes the Experimental Law Variations (ELVs) are fraught with inconsistency and intellectual dishonesty.
Writing in his Daily Telegraph column on Monday, Moore was adamant that the ELVs will not benefit the game.
"The reason for the increased pressure is the fact that International Rugby Board (IRB) rules state that two years before any World Cup there must be no law changes," he said in his weekly column.
"Thus, if the changes don't get the green light before 2009 they're dead in the water.
"The progress of the trials is said to have been unanimously positive. This is untrue," he stated.
"Moreover, the questions raised are legion - such as why is the Super 14 competition only trialling certain changes, and does this mean the others are defunct?
"The Tri-Nations, meanwhile, have not yet agreed which changes, if any, they will trial.
"How will these be picked and why? Again what happens to those not used? Under which laws will the imminent tours by Six Nations teams be played?
"If only four changes are to be used generally in the northern hemisphere next year, but another 11 in the Challenge Cup, how is this proof that any have been properly tested?
"No scientific company would get past first base with a new product trialled under these conditions.
"Given their far-reaching effect, does our game deserve anything less than properly regulated scrutiny?
"There was a timely reminder to the proponents of the changes that there is little wrong with rugby's laws as they stand, and that in the northern hemisphere, at least, the product is growing in popularity," added Moore.
"The Wasps' game against Gloucester drew a huge crowd, which contained unsegregated fans who co-existed without rancour, but with passion and knowledge. All were repaid by two teams who threw heart and soul into the game," said Moore.
"The Gloucester storming of the Wasps' stronghold was a great combined effort by an underdog pack and ambitious backs. The absorbing contest was lengthened by Wasps' resolute refusal to capitulate, so preventing it being a cricket score for the Glaws.
"Ask any of those who witnessed, close up, the enthralling contests of strength in the driving mauls in each of the above games whether they found them dull. If you report their responses honestly, you will say that they said the opposite.
"For those who like to smear the opponents of the ELVs as antediluvian, this game exposed the utter fallacy of their claims that the present laws do not work - they do.
"What has to be altered is the approach of the teams playing thereunder.
"You see, it just isn't true that everyone wants a simplistic game. Unfortunately the lie has been so often repeated that it is now accepted without protest. It is a little late in the day, but those who agree now have to stand up and shout about these canards.
"I suspect, like in the case of Brian Ashton, the decision has already been made by those in charge," he concluded.
