Get Newsletter

Problems mount for humiliated England

An admission that Danny Cipriani and assistant coach Mike Catt had a 'blazing row' and reports that players will not contribute to a post mortem enquiry further damaged the team's image.

ADVERTISEMENT

England chiefs refuted the report that the bust-up – which came shortly after Cipriani had been told he would not be in the squad – on the training ground had almost sparked a "mutiny" among the rest of the players.

They also denied that coach Stuart Lancaster, who appears likely to lose his job after the host nation's disastrous exit at the pool stage, told the squad to close ranks and not talk about the incident.  

"Danny and Mike were involved in a robust conversation on the training pitch following a misunderstanding around a training drill instruction," said a Rugby Football Union spokesman.Problems mount for humiliated England

"Both shook hands afterwards and the incident played no bearing on selection."

However, the need for a lengthy raking over the carcass of England's desperate World Cup campaign which saw them lose to Wales and Australia on their home ground Twickenham has been dismissed by both former assistant coach Mike Ford and World Cup winning centre Mike Tindall.

Ian Ritchie, Chief Executive of the RFU and whose own future is at risk given his decision last October to offer coach Stuart Lancaster a contract till 2020, has said there will be no immediate consequences until a detailed analysis has been done on how England became the first World Cup hosts to fail to reach the knockout stages.

ADVERTISEMENT

The trouble is that according to the Daily Telegraph the players are reluctant to make their opinions known as a similar exercise following the 2011 World Cup, which was a disaster on and off the pitch and cost Martin Johnson his job as coach, saw several of their statements made public when they had been promised they would be confidential.

"There is likely to be some critical feedback, but I am not sure many of them will trust that it will be an anonymous survey," a source close to the squad told the Telegraph.

"So I think they will be guarded in what they say or just not take part."

Some like veteran back row forward James Haskell have said they will contribute, but the 30-year-old has a lot less to lose than the younger members of the squad as his Test career is drawing to a close.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ford, who is coach of Bath and has said he does not wish to be considered for the England coaching role if it becomes vacant, was unequivocal when asked did he think there should be a lengthy inquest.

Among the many things likely to be up for discussion will be the controversial selection of Rugby League convert Sam Burgess.

He plays for Ford at Bath, but in the back row and not at centre where Lancaster put him at the expense of Luther Burrell, whose omission from the squad sowed seeds of discontent according to reports.

Divisions in the camp were also firmly denied on Wednesday by the RFU over the volatile Cipriani's bust-up on the training ground with Catt – hours after he was told he would not be in the squad.Problems mount for humiliated England

One report had suggested the fracas had all but sparked a mutiny and Lancaster had ordered the players not to speak about it publicly.

"I hope it doesn't take a long time. The review should not last three months," Ford told BBC Radio.

"You don't need any player feedback, because hopefully Stuart has been speaking to his captain and his leaders every day.

"So don't let the people involved go through that with their families, and have that kind of experience," added Ford, whose flyhalf son George was controversially dropped for the game with Wales and assistant coach Andy Farrell's son Owen replaced him.

Ford, who was England defence coach from 2006 to 2011, wondered what exactly the post mortem would drag up.

"The facilities weren't good enough? The Denver trip wasn't good enough?" said the 49-year-old.

"They didn't have enough coaches, or strength and conditioning? The food wasn't right at Pennyhill?

"All those things would have been meticulously planned anyway. So they know now."

Tindall, who was the captain of the 2011 team, for his part said he hoped there wouldn't be too much blood spilt in terms of recriminations.

"I hate the fact there is always a witch-hunt after," he told BBC radio.

"They have gone out, and have the tag of having the worst result England have ever had in a World Cup. That is going to burn any of those players.

"Fans say there are hurting from it – I guarantee players are hurting a hundred times over."

It is the latest revelation to throw light on divisions within the squad.

England made an ignominious exit from the tournament last weekend, becoming the first hosts to fail to reach the quarterfinals following defeats at Twickenham by Wales and Australia.

Agence France-Presse

Join free

Chasing The Sun | Series 1 Episode 1

Fresh Starts | Episode 1 | Will Skelton

ABBIE WARD: A BUMP IN THE ROAD

Aotearoa Rugby Podcast | Episode 9

James Cook | The Big Jim Show | Full Episode

New Zealand victorious in TENSE final | Cathay/HSBC Sevens Day Three Men's Highlights

New Zealand crowned BACK-TO-BACK champions | Cathay/HSBC Sevens Day Three Women's Highlights

Japan Rugby League One | Bravelupus v Steelers | Full Match Replay

Write A Comment